-
In total there are 17 users online :: 1 registered, 0 hidden and 16 guests (based on users active over the past 60 minutes)
Most users ever online was 1086 on Mon Jul 01, 2024 9:03 am
LITERATURE ABUSE: AMERICA'S HIDDEN AFFLICTION
Forum rules
Do not promote books in this forum. Instead, promote your books in either Authors: Tell us about your FICTION book! or Authors: Tell us about your NON-FICTION book!.
All other Community Rules apply in this and all other forums.
Do not promote books in this forum. Instead, promote your books in either Authors: Tell us about your FICTION book! or Authors: Tell us about your NON-FICTION book!.
All other Community Rules apply in this and all other forums.
- Constance963
-
Intern
- Posts: 161
- Joined: Tue Nov 20, 2007 6:25 pm
- 16
[quote="MadArchitect"]Actually, if they're going to try and adapt an already worthwhile book, I'd rather they send the screenwriter in with a butcher's knife rather than try to render a straight adaptation of a book. What's the point of making the movie just like the book? I say, do something interesting with the source material, and if it sucks, we've still got the book. But the only way to get something better is to take some risks, right?[/quote]
I do see your point MadArchitect, there is definitely something to be said for artistic interpretation. But I can't help it I get protective as if I had written it myself.....LOL
I do see your point MadArchitect, there is definitely something to be said for artistic interpretation. But I can't help it I get protective as if I had written it myself.....LOL
My wedding day! 08-08-08
-
-
Almost Comfortable
- Posts: 15
- Joined: Mon Jan 21, 2008 10:29 am
- 16
- Been thanked: 1 time
This is not funny, every single one of these is true of me except for 21 (my library's limit is 50 items, and even I couldn't handle that.) and 25. I have never once regretted loving books! I pity people who don't.
I feel the same way as MadArchitecht. I won't watch movies based on my favorite books anymore. "Because of Winn-Dixie" was the last movie that I saw that "followed the book perfectly," and of course it didn't really, because a book is an experience you have inside your head, and it can never be duplicated, especially by some guy in Hollywood who's never met you.
I don't mind movies like "Ella Enchanted" and "The Count of Monte Cristo," because they are so ludicrously different from the books they're *loosely* based on that they don't interfere with your memories of how a character looked and talked in your imagination.
I feel the same way as MadArchitecht. I won't watch movies based on my favorite books anymore. "Because of Winn-Dixie" was the last movie that I saw that "followed the book perfectly," and of course it didn't really, because a book is an experience you have inside your head, and it can never be duplicated, especially by some guy in Hollywood who's never met you.
I don't mind movies like "Ella Enchanted" and "The Count of Monte Cristo," because they are so ludicrously different from the books they're *loosely* based on that they don't interfere with your memories of how a character looked and talked in your imagination.
For what, though some did not believe? Shall their unbelief make the faith of God without effect?
God forbid: yea, let God be true, and every man a liar, as it is written, "That thou mightest be justified in thy words, and overcome, when thou art judged." - Romans 3:3-4
God forbid: yea, let God be true, and every man a liar, as it is written, "That thou mightest be justified in thy words, and overcome, when thou art judged." - Romans 3:3-4
I'm with the crowd here...I tend to avoid based-on-a-book movies of books I've read. Although, if it's not Hollywood attempting it, it can turn out quite well. What most books require is time and loving devotion, to turn out a good visual rendition.
Bad = the first Harry Potter movie. I spent the whole time thinking "Okay, now we'll see chapter 2..."
Good = the British film "I Capture the Castle". Follows the book quite closely, but is lovely, and almost (dare I say) perfect...
Not too bad = "The Power of One". The story of the novel was too big for the movie, but they did capture a lot of the feel of the book...even if they did add the romance.
[Needless to say, LOTR was brilliant, but I'll leave that one out for now...]
The winners are the books that get the BBC mini-series treatment. Pride and Prejudice. Dune. Gormenghast. All lovingly treated, and rather delicious...
But then, they're not hollywood.
Bad = the first Harry Potter movie. I spent the whole time thinking "Okay, now we'll see chapter 2..."
Good = the British film "I Capture the Castle". Follows the book quite closely, but is lovely, and almost (dare I say) perfect...
Not too bad = "The Power of One". The story of the novel was too big for the movie, but they did capture a lot of the feel of the book...even if they did add the romance.
[Needless to say, LOTR was brilliant, but I'll leave that one out for now...]
The winners are the books that get the BBC mini-series treatment. Pride and Prejudice. Dune. Gormenghast. All lovingly treated, and rather delicious...
But then, they're not hollywood.
"All Beings are the Owners of their Deeds, the Heirs to their Deeds."
- Ophelia
-
- Oddly Attracted to Books
- Posts: 1543
- Joined: Sun Nov 25, 2007 7:33 am
- 16
- Location: France
- Been thanked: 35 times
Loricat,
I thought the Harry Potter films were OK, but could not replace the books . There were many excellent ideas, such as the location of the Dining Hall and the choice of some actors, such as the one who plays McGonegal.
I also admire BBC mini-series: Apart from Pride and Prejudice, I also love North and South, and MiddleMarch, and, the best for last Vanity Fair.
(absolutely brilliant).
I found out later that, alas, many BBC mini-series fall short of those standards ( the only way I can see them is by buying the DVDs, which are not cheap):
Emma is dreadful, the Charlotte Bronte series are old-fashioned and lifeless (in my opinion) for example.
I thought the Harry Potter films were OK, but could not replace the books . There were many excellent ideas, such as the location of the Dining Hall and the choice of some actors, such as the one who plays McGonegal.
I also admire BBC mini-series: Apart from Pride and Prejudice, I also love North and South, and MiddleMarch, and, the best for last Vanity Fair.
(absolutely brilliant).
I found out later that, alas, many BBC mini-series fall short of those standards ( the only way I can see them is by buying the DVDs, which are not cheap):
Emma is dreadful, the Charlotte Bronte series are old-fashioned and lifeless (in my opinion) for example.
Ophelia.
- Ophelia
-
- Oddly Attracted to Books
- Posts: 1543
- Joined: Sun Nov 25, 2007 7:33 am
- 16
- Location: France
- Been thanked: 35 times
France is afflicted too.
Jan,
Someone in France has given me proof that the French were also afflicted.
This is from a website called La Biblioteque d'Allie-- for the moment only for the reading of the bilingual among our afflicted BT members.
http://meslectures.over-blog.com/article-5538113-6.html
Someone in France has given me proof that the French were also afflicted.
This is from a website called La Biblioteque d'Allie-- for the moment only for the reading of the bilingual among our afflicted BT members.
To be completed by:LCA: Lecteurs Compulsifs Anonymes
LCA_4Le LCA (Lecteurs Compulsifs Anonymes) est ne d'un commentaire innocemment lance chez Flo suite a un de ses billets. L'idee a fait boule de neige et Flo a ecrit un billet sur "comment ameliorer son cas" en tant que LCA. D'autres billets ont vu le jour sur la blogosphere. Entre autres, toujours chez Flo, une mise en garde sur le danger d'etre LCA. Hilde, notre porte-parole, a lance quant a elle une grande enquete sur l'age des LCA. Lou et Caro[line] ont aussi fait un billet sur cette pathologie qui nous affecte.
Qu'est-ce que le syndrome du LCA? C'est toute une panoplie de symptomes... en voici quelques uns:
1- Le LCA ne peut s'empecher de noter TOUS les titres qui lui font envie. Cette manie s'accompagne regulierement d'une passion pour les listes en tout genre: listes papier, liste informatisees, listes sous logiciel special ou sous excel, en vue de ne pas perdre de vue la liste faramineuse de titres qui lui font envie.
2- Le LCA devrait, par principe, ne plus etre admis dans les librairies. Il y vide regulierement son portefeuille et ne peut s'empecher d'etre attire par la grande majorite des livres qui s'offrent a lui. Il ressort rarement de la dite librairie les mains vides. Il fait la joie des libraires.
3- Le LCA parle de son blog, de ses lectures, de ses copains de la blogospheres a tous ses amis. Certains le croient toque et se posent des questions sur son etat mental. Le LCA s'en fout.
4- Le LCA achete et note plus de livres qu'il ne pourra jamais lire dans toute sa vie.
http://meslectures.over-blog.com/article-5538113-6.html
Ophelia.
- bibliophile_18
-
Master Debater
- Posts: 21
- Joined: Wed Jul 16, 2008 11:38 pm
- 15
So does being an LA mean that I should just let my fiance finance my 'habit' while I grow more and more rabid? j 0_o That would be nice, but I don't see that happening. And anyway...I prefer movies with no ties to books. The first Harry Potter movie was the only one that followed any sort of 'near-the-book' accuracy. Of course, this is Hollywood, so they're gonna focus more on the 'hero' of the story and not the developing relationship between Ron and Hermione like the books do, now will they? (As I have seen from movie five, there's no chance for that relationship to ever be settled into the series. and they're doing a two part-movie seven. What's the second part going to be called? Harry Potter and The Death of Voldemort?)
Yes, I'm a very serious LA, the only one that didn't apply was number 20. My libraries limit books to no more than 20 and I take about 30-45 depending on their thickness, level of difficulty, and how close the nearest book store is.
Yes, I'm a very serious LA, the only one that didn't apply was number 20. My libraries limit books to no more than 20 and I take about 30-45 depending on their thickness, level of difficulty, and how close the nearest book store is.